Skip to main content

Your FMEA, scored and ranked.

Score each failure mode for severity, occurrence and detection, and see its RPN, its rank and what the rules say to do, ready for Word.

The assessment

Failure modes

  1. F1
  2. F2
  3. F3
  4. F4

Ranking for Line 3, Exemplar 10 mg/mL injection

RankFailure modeS × O × DDecision
1F1 RABS glove pinhole: ingress into Grade A5 × 4 × 3 = 60ActRPN 40 or more
2F4 Vial neck crack: closure integrity lost5 × 1 × 4 = 20Actseverity 5 with detection 4
3F3 Low fill volume: under-filled vials4 × 3 × 3 = 36Act, or accept with a rationale QA approves
4F2 Stopper not seated: closure integrity lost5 × 2 × 2 = 20Act, or accept with a rationale QA approves

Scales and rules

ScoreSeverityOccurrenceDetection
5Could harm a patient, such as loss of sterilityMore than once in 10 batchesNot detectable
4Batch fails a specificationOnce in 10 to 100 batchesFound only by chance, or by a check not proven for it
3Within specification, a quality attribute affectedOnce in 100 to 1,000 batchesLikely found by a periodic or sampled check
2GMP non-conformance, no product effectRarer than once in 1,000 batchesFound by a validated check of every unit or batch
1No noticeable effectNone in over 5,000 batches of relevant dataAlways found: a validated automatic check stops the line
  1. Controls a regulation or GMP guideline requires are in place before scoring and are never accepted away by an RPN.
  2. Act when the RPN is 40 or more, or when severity is 5 and detection 4 or 5.
  3. From 20 to 39, act or record a rationale for accepting, approved by QA.
  4. Below 20, accept and review at the next periodic review.

Where each number comes from.

The RPN is severity × occurrence × detection, as WHO’s quality risk management guideline (TRS 981 Annex 2) defines it. Rows are ranked by what the rules say to act on, then by RPN, then by severity and detection.

Neither ICH Q9(R1) nor WHO sets the scales or the thresholds. These are the example ones of FMEA and the RPN, QRM-SC-02 v3, which scores the same line: replace them with your own approved scales and rules.

Keep the FMEA with its evidence.

In Seal each failure mode keeps its causes, controls and the basis for each score, so a failed verification or a complaint links back to the row it reopens.