Manufacturing Software: A Buyer’s Guide (2024)

Manufacturing Software: A Buyer’s Guide (2024)

author image
Tali Kauffmann
Product Marketer at Seal
7 minute read

Manufacturing software helps manufacturers streamline production, reduce errors, and improve efficiency. This article explains what manufacturing software is, the different types available, and how it has evolved from paper-based to digital systems. We'll cover Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES), Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), and Electronic Batch Records (EBR). We'll also look at other technologies like IoT and AI, the benefits of cloud-based solutions, how to choose the right software, common challenges in getting started, and how to measure success.

What is Manufacturing Software?

Manufacturing software is a tool designed to help manufacturers manage and streamline their production processes. It refers to a variety of software solutions that make production processes more efficient and less prone to errors.

There are several types of manufacturing software, each serving a unique role in the production process.

Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES): These systems monitor and control the production process on the factory floor. They help ensure that manufacturing operations are executed efficiently and according to plan.

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP): ERP systems integrate all facets of an operation, including planning, purchasing, inventory, sales, marketing, finance, and human resources. In manufacturing, they help manage everything from supply chain logistics to production scheduling.

Electronic Batch Records (EBR): EBRs replace traditional paper-based records used to document the production of each batch of products. These digital records capture all relevant data during the manufacturing process, ensuring accuracy and compliance with industry standards. They provide real-time tracking and are easily accessible for audits and reviews.

Visual shows all the types of manufacturing software, mapping both Opvia and other vendor solutions onto the different stages of the supply chain.

The Evolution of Manufacturing Systems

Manufacturing systems have come a long way from the days of paper-based processes to today’s advanced digital solutions.

Paper-Based Systems vs. Digital Systems

In the past, manufacturers used paper-based systems to manage production. This involved manually tracking inventory, recording batch production details, and maintaining records by hand. While it got the job done, paper-based systems were prone to errors, time-consuming, and cumbersome. Records could easily be lost or damaged, and manual data entry often led to mistakes.

Digital systems have revolutionised this process. By automating tasks and storing data electronically, they reduce errors and save time. Digital records are much easier to store, search, and retrieve, making them far more accessible. Shifting to digital systems, however, also requires an initial investment in technology and training for employees.

This image compares paper based systems to digital Systems (MES/EBR).

The Future of Shop Floor Technology in Life Sciences

Life sciences manufacturers are increasingly turning towards connected manufacturing. This refers to the process of integrating all parts of the production process so they can communicate and work together efficiently. This enables smoother operations, immediate issue detection, and reduced downtime, which are all critical for maintaining high-quality standards.

Internet of Things (IoT)

IoT involves placing sensors on machines to collect data about their performance and sending this information to a central system. These sensors monitor key parameters like temperature, humidity, and pressure—vital for making sure of the quality and safety of pharmaceutical or biotech products. Real-time monitoring provides live updates on production status and machine health, allowing for immediate responses to potential issues. For example, if a sensor detects a temperature change that could affect product quality, it alerts the maintenance team to take action right away.

Some common use cases for IoT in this setting include:

  • Monitoring machine performance for efficiency
  • Alerting maintenance teams to service needs before equipment failures.
  • Detecting hazardous conditions like gas leaks in real-time.

This image illustrates how IoT sensors or devices can be placed around a shop floor and relay information back to a dashboard for predictive maintenance or hazard detection.

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

There is no shortage of talk about the importance of AI today, and manufacturing is no exception. One of the key ways that AI fits into connected manufacturing is by analysing data from IoT sensors in order to make more informed decisions. AI is particularly useful for predictive maintenance, which forecasts when machines will need servicing based on historical and real-time data. This kind of proactive approach helps prevent unexpected breakdowns and keeps production running smoothly. AI can a lso make production more efficient by analysing data to improve schedules and reduce waste.

The most frequently used use cases here are:

  • Predicting maintenance.
  • Reducing material waste by improving resource use.
  • Detecting defects early to ensure high product quality.

Cloud-Based Manufacturing Solutions

Another aspect of manufacturing systems that has largely become the norm is cloud-based software. While some manufacturers still use on-premise storage or are turning towards edge computing, many are moving towards cloud software solutions for data storage and management over the internet.

One major benefit of this, of course, is scalability. Cloud systems allow manufacturers to quickly adjust their resource needs without investing tons into additional hardware. If more storage or processing power is needed, it can be accessed immediately.

Cost-effectiveness is another advantage, as many cloud services use a pay-as-you-go model. This means manufacturers only pay for the resources they use, which can be more economical than maintaining extensive on-site IT infrastructure.

Cloud solutions are also easier to update and maintain. The service provider handles updates, ensuring that manufacturers always have the latest features and security improvements without the hassle of manual upgrades. What’s more, cloud systems can be accessed from anywhere with an internet connection, making it easy for teams to work remotely or access crucial information on the go.

This image compares on-premise to cloud based storage.

How to Choose the Right Manufacturing Software

Choosing the right manufacturing software is a critical decision that can significantly impact your operations. Some of the key factors to consider are:

  • Cost
  • Scalability
  • Ease of Use
  • Integrations

Assessing Your Manufacturing Needs

Before selecting software, it's important to evaluate your current systems and identify any gaps. Start by analysing your existing processes and pinpoint areas where efficiency can be improved. Look at how data is currently managed and how accessible it is across your team.

Once you've identified the gaps, prioritise the features based on your business needs. This might include better inventory management, enhanced quality control, or improved document accessibility. Understanding your unique challenges will help you choose software that addresses your specific requirements.

Evaluating Software Options

When it comes to evaluating software options, a side-by-side comparison of popular solutions can be really helpful. You should look at several different solutions to see how they fit your needs. Check how each software handles production management, inventory control, quality assurance, document management, and integrations. For production management, see if the software can streamline workflows and provide real-time updates. For inventory control, make sure it can track stock levels accurately and automate replenishment. Quality assurance is important too, so find out if the software integrates quality checks smoothly into the production process. For document management, ensure that it lets you access and organise critical documents easily. Also, check if the software can connect well with your existing enterprise systems.

Comparing Electronic Batch Record (EBR) systems

1. MasterControl

MasterControl specialises in solutions for pharmaceutical and other regulated industries, offering solutions for manufacturing and quality control. One of the products they offer is MasterControl EBR.

Key features:

This image assesses Mastercontrol's EBR on a series of 7 criteria.

2. Veeva Systems

Veeva Systems offers a Batch Release solution, a platform designed for enterprises in industries including pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, and CDMOs. Introduced in 2023, it automates the aggregation, review, and traceability of batch-related data and content.

Key features:

  • End-to-end solution for faster and more confident GMP release and market shipment decisions
  • Integrates data and content from QMS, LIMS, ERP, and Vault RIM, for easier collaboration with external partners.
  • Streamlines batch release processes

This image shows an evalutation of Veeva Systems software on 7 key criteria.

3. Ideagen

Ideagen provides information management software that helps companies with compliance, regulatory, and risk management, particularly in highly regulated industries like aviation, financial services, and life sciences.

Key features:

This image shows an evaluation of Ideagen software on 7 key criteria.

4. 🌟Opvia 🌟

Opvia's cloud platform simplifies how organisations manage and execute GxP procedures, integrating every step and data point across the product lifecycle. By digitising procedures, the platform automates compliance and data workflows, making it easier to maintain standards and efficiency.

Key features:

  • Integrates with an extensive range of devices, systems, & tools, including, laptops, tablets, and third-party software solutions.
  • Offers powerful no-code tools that allow users to tailor solutions to their process needs without extensive programming.
  • Provides end-to-end solutions to connect the entire product life-cycle e.g. ELN, LIMS, QMS, MES etc.

Technical specifications:

  • Universal compatibility with any screen size.
  • GxP-ready platform and fully compliant with all relevant regulatory standards.

Implementing Manufacturing Software

Implementing manufacturing software requires careful planning and execution. Start by clearly defining your goals, like boosting efficiency or improving quality control. Get key people from different departments involved early to make sure their needs are considered, and put together a dedicated team to manage the implementation, including IT specialists, process engineers, and end-users.

Next, focus on data migration. Begin with a data audit to check the quality and relevance of your existing data. Clean the data to remove duplicates and fix errors, then develop a detailed plan to transfer it from your old systems to the new software. Training and change management are also crucial. Hold thorough training sessions so everyone knows how to use the new system. Explain the benefits of the new software to ease any resistance and offer ongoing support to help people adjust.

After that, it's time for testing and validation. Run thorough tests to make sure the software works as expected and let end-users try it out in real-world scenarios to catch any issues before the full rollout.

One of the biggest challenges you'll face is resistance to change. To get everyone on board, involve key people early and provide plenty of training so they feel comfortable with the new system. Data quality is another hurdle; it's important to clean and validate your data thoroughly to keep everything accurate. Integrating the new software with your existing systems can be tricky, so work closely with your software provider to ensure everything fits together smoothly. Finally, technical difficulties are inevitable, so having a dedicated IT team ready to tackle any problems will help make the transition smoother.

What a successful implementation looks like

Quality Wellness successfully implemented Opvia’s QMS and EBR systems to address their challenges. The QMS system provided a centralised digital platform for managing quality documents and compliance records, improving audit readiness and collaboration. The EBR system automated production workflows, ensured recipe adherence, and integrated real-time quality checks, resulting in consistent product quality and reduced waste. This case study demonstrates how choosing the right software can lead to significant operational improvements.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/05sH4htNB6U?si=ckNegjrlsxxgdRfD" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Measuring the Success of Your Software

To gauge the effectiveness of your new manufacturing software, track key performance indicators (KPIs) that reflect its impact on your operations.

Efficiency Gains

Production efficiency measures the ratio of actual output to the maximum possible output. It's a crucial metric for determining how well your software is improving the production process.

Production efficiency = (actual output / maximum possible output) x 100%

Cycle time reduction tracks the decrease in the time taken to complete a production cycle. This helps in identifying how much quicker the processes have become post-implementation.

Cycle time reduction = [(old cycle time - new cycle time) / old cycle time] x 100%

Error Reduction

To assess improvements in product quality and cost savings, you can monitor the defect rate. This metric measures the number of defects per unit produced.

Defect rate = (number of defects / total units produced) x 100%

Rework costs measure the expenses associated with reworking defective products. This helps understand the cost savings achieved by reducing errors.

Rework cost reduction = [(old rework costs - new rework costs) / old rework costs] x 100%

Operational Metrics

Downtime reduction tracks the decrease in machine or system downtime, showing how well the software is minimising interruptions.

Downtime reduction = [(old downtime - new downtime) / old downtime] x 100%

Throughput improvement measures the increase in the number of units produced over a given period, indicating how much more efficient the production line is.

Throughput improvement = [(new throughput - old throughput) / old throughput] x 100%

Quality Metrics

First pass yield (FPY) is the percentage of products that pass quality checks the first time without requiring rework. This metric is vital for understanding the effectiveness of your quality control processes.

First pass yield = (number of good units / total units produced) x 100%

Customer satisfaction is another important metric that monitors feedback and satisfaction levels from customers after the software implementation. This qualitative metric provides insights into how the changes are perceived by your end-users.